•  
  •  
 

Corresponding Author

郑小燕，女，博士，副教授.E-mail：xiaoyanzheng@fafu.edu.cn

Abstract

Currently,life cycle cost analysis (LCCA ) and life cycle assessment (LCA ) methods are commonly used to assess the economic and environmental impacts of pavement during the whole life cycle.However,there are drawbacks in the application of LCCA and LCA methods,such as a large amount of data and multiple data categories,which lead to a tedious evaluation process.In view of this,some scholars have tried to combine building information modeling (BIM ) with LCCA and LCA methods to optimize the evaluation process.In the pavement field,the combination of LCCA and LCA with BIM is still in its infancy,lacking a summary of relevant research results.Therefore,this paper summarized the research on LCCA,LCA,and LCCA-LCA methods for pavement,as well as their combination with BIM to explore the existing problems and challenges.It is found that the application of BIM can optimize the LCCA and LCA processes and realize the dynamic coordination of design and evaluation.However,the low integration degree and the lack of unified data format standards between modeling software and evaluation software hinder the application and development of BIM.

Publication Date

6-27-2024

DOI

10.14048/j.issn.1671-2579.2024.03.010

First Page

85

Last Page

94,103

Submission Date

February 2025

Reference

[1]中华人民共和国国家发展和改革委员会 .中华人民共和国国民经济和社会发展第十四个五年规划和 2035 年远景 目 标 纲 要 [A/OL ]. (2021 -03-23) [2022 -10-08].https ://www .ndrc .gov.cn/fggz/fzzlgh/gjfzgh/ 202103 /t20210323 _1270102 .html .National Development and Reform Commission .The 14th five-year plan for national economic and social development of the People ’s Republic of China and the long-range objectives through the year 2035 [A/OL ].(2021 -03-23) [2022 -10-08].https ://www .ndrc .gov.cn/fggz/fzzlgh/gjfzgh/ 202103 /t20210323 _1270102 .html .
[2]SANTOS J ,FERREIRA A ,FLINTSCH G .A life cycle assessment model for pavement management :methodology and computational framework [J].International Journal of Pavement Engineering ,2015 ,16(3):268-286.
[3]ZHENG X Y ,EASA S M ,YANG Z X ,et al .Life-cycle sustainability assessment of pavement maintenance alternatives :methodology and case study [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2019 ,213:659-672.
[4]ZHU D L ,WANG J ,GU L X .Environmental benefit analysis of hot central plant recycling asphalt pavement based on LCA [J].IOP Conference Series :Earth and Environmental Science ,2021 ,766(1):012101 .
[5]VAN ELDIK M A ,VAHDATIKHAKI F ,DOS SANTOS J M O ,et al .BIM-based environmental impact assessment for infrastructure design projects [J].Automation in Construction ,2020 ,120:103379 .
[6]BUENO C ,FABRICIO M M .Comparative analysis between a complete LCA study and results from a BIM-LCA plug-in [J].Automation in Construction ,2018 ,90:188-200.
[7]MARZOUK M ,AZAB S ,METAWIE M .BIM-based approach for optimizing life cycle costs of sustainable buildings [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2018 ,188:217-226.
[8]BABASHAMSI P ,MD YUSOFF N I ,CEYLAN H ,et al .Evaluation of pavement life cycle cost analysis :Review and analysis [J].International Journal of Pavement Research and Technology ,2016 ,9(4):241-254.
[9]罗启添 ,游庆龙 ,刘福顺 .道路全寿命周期费用分析概述[J].公路交通科技 ,2010 ,27(增刊 1):155-158.LUO Qitian ,YOU Qinglong ,LIU Fushun .Overview of road life cycle cost analysis [J].Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development ,2010 ,27(sup 1):155-158.
[10]万礼锋 ,黄加富 ,蒋慧杰 ,等.公路项目中全生命周期成本方法应用研究 [J].天津理工大学学报 ,2006 ,22(5):63-65.WAN Lifeng ,HUANG Jiafu ,JIANG Huijie ,et al .Study on the application of LCCA method in pavement project [J].Journal of Tianjin University of Technology ,2006 ,22(5):63-65.
[11]NICUȚĂ A M ,ANDREI R ,BUDESCU M .Comparative assessment on the ecologic and economic impact of new road technologies integrating reclaimed asphalt pavement[J].Advanced Engineering Forum ,2013 (8/9):147-156.
[12]QIAO Y N ,DAWSON A R ,PARRY T ,et al .Evaluating the effects of climate change on road maintenance intervention strategies and life-cycle costs [J].Transportation Research Part D :Transport and Environment ,2015 ,41:492-503.
[13]MIRZADEH I ,BIRGISSON B .Accommodating energy price volatility in life cycle cost analysis of asphalt pavements [J].Journal of Civil Engineering and Management ,2016 ,22(8):1001 -1008 .
[14]MEHANY M S H M ,GUGGEMOS A A .Risk-managed lifecycle costing for asphalt road construction and maintenance projects under performance-based contracts[J].ASCE-ASME Journal of Risk and Uncertainty in Engineering Systems ,Part A :Civil Engineering ,2016 ,2(4).
[15]CHEN J S ,YANG C H ,LEE C T .Field evaluation of porous asphalt course for life-cycle cost analysis [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2019 ,221:20-26.
[16]QIAO Y N ,DAVE E ,PARRY T ,et al .Life cycle costs analysis of reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP ) under future climate [J].Sustainability ,2019 ,11(19):5414 .
[17]RIEKSTINS A ,HARITONOVS V ,ABOLINS V ,et al .Life cycle cost analysis of BBTM and traditional asphalt concretes in Latvia [C]//Engineering for Rural Development .Latvia University of Life Sciences and Technologies ,2019 .[18]QIAO Y N ,SANTOS J ,STONER A M K ,et al .Climate change impacts on asphalt road pavement construction and maintenance :An economic life cycle assessment of adaptation measures in the State of Virginia ,United States[J].Journal of Industrial Ecology ,2020 ,24(2):342-355.
[19]PAN Y Y ,SHANG Y ,LIU G Q ,et al .Cost-effectiveness evaluation of pavement maintenance treatments using multiple regression and life-cycle cost analysis [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2021 ,292:123461 .
[20]JUNG H ,OLI T ,NAM J ,et al .Life-cycle cost analysis on application of asphalt and concrete pavement overlay [J].Applied Sciences ,2022 ,12(10):5098 .
[21]QIAO Y N ,GUO Y R ,STONER A M K ,et al .Impacts of future climate change on flexible road pavement economics :A life cycle costs analysis of 24 case studies across the United States [J].Sustainable Cities and Society ,2022 ,80:103773 .
[22]JIANG R ,WU P .Estimation of environmental impacts of roads through life cycle assessment :A critical review and future directions [J].Transportation Research Part D :Transport and Environment ,2019 ,77:148-163.
[23]张倩 ,徐剑 ,张金喜 .路面工程生命周期评价 (LCA )方法应用研究 [J].中外公路 ,2015 ,35(5):346-350.ZHANG Qian ,XU Jian ,ZHANG Jinxi .Study on the application of life cycle assessment (LCA ) method in pavement engineering [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2015 ,35(5):346-350.
[24]INYIM P ,PEREYRA J ,BIENVENU M ,et al .Environmental assessment of pavement infrastructure :A systematic review [J]. Journal of Environmental Management ,2016 ,176:128-138.
[25]SUH S .Functions ,commodities and environmental impacts in an ecological –economic model [J].Ecological Economics ,2004 ,48(4):451-467.
[26]CRAWFORD R H ,BONTINCK P A ,STEPHAN A ,et al .Hybrid life cycle inventory methods ：A review [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2018 ,172:1273 -1288 .
[27]KLÜPPEL H J .The Revision of ISO Standards 14040 -3-ISO 14040 :Environmental management-Life cycle assessment-Principles and framework-ISO 14044 :Environmental management-Life cycle assessment Requirements and guidelines [J].The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment ,2005 ,10(3):165.
[28]章 毅 ,刘 伟 杰 .路 面 生 命 周 期 生 态 环 境 影 响 评 价 研 究 综述[J].中外公路 ,2013 ,33(3):348-352.ZHANG Yi ,LIU Weijie .Summary of research on eco-environmental impact assessment of pavement life cycle[J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2013 ,33(3):348-352.
[29]翟一杰 ,张天祚 ,申晓旭 ,等.生命周期评价方法研究进展[J].资源科学 ,2021 ,43(3):446-455.ZHAI Yijie ,ZHANG Tianzuo ,SHEN Xiaoxu ,et al .Development of life cycle assessment method [J].Resources Science ,2021 ,43(3):446-455.
[30]TOKEDE O O ,WHITTAKER A ,MANKAA R ,et al .Life cycle assessment of asphalt variants in infrastructures :The case of lignin in Australian road pavements [J].Structures ,2020 ,25:190-199.
[31]LIU Y Y ,WANG Y Q ,AN D .Life-cycle CO2 emissions and influential factors for asphalt highway construction and maintenance activities in China [J].International Journal of Sustainable Transportation ,2018 ,12(7):497-509.
[32]GIANI M I ,DOTELLI G ,BRANDINI N ,et al.Comparative life cycle assessment of asphalt pavements using reclaimed asphalt ,warm mix technology and cold in-place recycling [J].Resources ,Conservation and Recycling ,2015 ,104:224-238.
[33]GSCHÖSSER F ,WALLBAUM H ,BOESCH M E .Life-cycle assessment of the production of Swiss road materials[J].Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering ,2012 ,24(2):168-176.
[34]TRELOAR G J ,LOVE P E D ,CRAWFORD R H .Hybrid life-cycle inventory for road construction and use [J].Journal of Construction Engineering and Management ,2004 ,130(1):43-49.
[35]YU B ,LU Q .Life cycle assessment of pavement :Methodology and case study [J].Transportation Research Part D :Transport and Environment ,2012 ,17(5):380-388.
[36]VIDAL R ,MOLINER E ,MARTÍNEZ G ,et al .Life cycle assessment of hot mix asphalt and zeolite-based warm mix asphalt with reclaimed asphalt pavement [J].Resources ,Conservation and Recycling ,2013 ,74:101-114.
[37]ARAÚJO J P C ,OLIVEIRA J R M ,SILVA H M R D .The importance of the use phase on the LCA of environmentally friendly solutions for asphalt road pavements [J].Transportation Research Part D :Transport and Environment ,2014 ,32:97-110.
[38]ANASTASIOU E K ,LIAPIS A ,PAPAYIANNI I .Comparative life cycle assessment of concrete road pavements using industrial by-products as alternative materials [J].Resources ,Conservation and Recycling ,2015 ,101:1-8.
[39]SMITH S H ,DURHAM S A .A cradle to gate LCA framework for emissions and energy reduction in concrete pavement mixture design [J].International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment ,2016 ,5(1):23-33.
[40]FARINA A ,ZANETTI M C ,SANTAGATA E ,et al .Life cycle assessment applied to bituminous mixtures containing recycled materials :Crumb rubber and reclaimed asphalt pavement [J].Resources ,Conservation and Recycling ,2017 ,117:204-212.
[41]SANTOS J ,FLINTSCH G ,FERREIRA A .Environmental and economic assessment of pavement construction and management practices for enhancing pavement sustainability [J].Resources ,Conservation and Recycling ,2017 ,116:15-31.
[42]JIANG R ,WU C K ,SONG Y Z ,et al .Estimating carbon emissions from road use ,maintenance and rehabilitation through a hybrid life cycle assessment approach :A case study [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2020 ,277:123276 .
[43]JIANG Q ,WANG F S ,LIU Q T ,et al .Energy consumption and environment performance analysis of induction-healed asphalt pavement by life cycle assessment (LCA )[J].Materials ,2021 ,14(5):1244 .
[44]CHEN X D ,WANG H ,HORTON R ,et al .Life-cycle assessment of climate change impact on time-dependent carbon-footprint of asphalt pavement [J].Transportation Research Part D :Transport and Environment ,2021 ,91:102697 .
[45]PLEȘCAN C ,BARTA M ,MAXINEASA S G ,et al .Life cycle assessment of concrete pavement rehabilitation :A Romanian case study [J].Applied Sciences ,2022 ,12(4):1769 .
[46]TANG Y X ,XIAO J Z ,LIU Q ,et al.Natural gravel-recycled aggregate concrete applied in rural highway pavement :Material properties and life cycle assessment [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2022 ,334:130219 .
[47]HOSSAIN M U ,WONG J J Y ,NG S T ,et al .Sustainable design of pavement systems in highly urbanized context :A lifecycle assessment [J].Journal of Environmental Management ,2022 ,305:114410 .
[48]郑玲 ,张琪 ,杨密圆 .生命周期成本与生命周期评价 :集成模型与协同路径 [J].会计之友 ,2020 (9):47-50.ZHENG Ling ,ZHANG Qi ,YANG Miyuan .Life cycle cost and life cycle assessment :Integrated model and collaborative path [J].Friends of Accounting ,2020 (9):47-50.
[49]UMER A ,HEWAGE K ,HAIDER H ,et al .Sustainability evaluation framework for pavement technologies :An integrated life cycle economic and environmental trade-off analysis [J].Transportation Research Part D :Transport and Environment ,2017 ,53:88-101.
[50]SANTOS J ,FERREIRA A ,FLINTSCH G .A multi-objective optimization-based pavement management decision-support system for enhancing pavement sustainability [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2017 ,164:1380 -1393 .
[51]CARVALHO J P ,VILLASCHI F S ,BRAGANÇA L .Assessing life cycle environmental and economic impacts of building construction solutions with BIM [J].Sustainability ,2021 ,13(16):8914 .
[52]孙建诚 ,朱双晗 ,蒋浩鹏 .BIM 技术在公路工程中的应用研究 [J].中外公路 ,2019 ,39(4):294-297.SUN Jiancheng ,ZHU Shuanghan ,JIANG Haopeng .Application of BIM technology to highway engineering [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2019 ,39(4):294-297.
[53]SHIN Y S ,CHO K .BIM application to select appropriate design alternative with consideration of LCA and LCCA[J].Mathematical Problems in Engineering ,2015 ,2015 :281640 .
[54]VITÁSEK S ,MATĚJKA P .Utilization of BIM for automation of quantity takeoffs and cost estimation in transport infrastructure construction projects in the Czech Republic [J].IOP Conference Series :Materials Science and Engineering ,2017 ,236:012110 .
[55]胡 迎 迎 .BIM 技 术 下 研 究 道 路 桥 梁 造 价 全 过 程 控 制 [J].工程建设与设计 ,2017 (6):188-189.HU Yingying .Research on road and bridge whole process cost control under BIM technology [J].Construction & Design for Engineering ,2017 (6):188-189.
[56]SANTOS R ,COSTA A A ,SILVESTRE J D ,et al .Integration of LCA and LCC analysis within a BIM-based environment [J].Automation in Construction ,2019 ,103:127-149.
[57]DÍAZ B ,RIVERA M ,RODRIGUEZ S ,et al .Time and cost optimization for road projects through BIM [C]//2019 Congreso Internacional de Innovación y Tendencias en Ingenieria (CONIITI ).Bogota ,Colombia .IEEE ,2019 .
[58]ZANNI M ,SHARPE T ,LAMMERS P ,et al .Developing a methodology for integration of w hole life costs into BIM processes to assist design decision making [J].Buildings ,2019 ,9(5):114.
[59]KAEWUNRUEN S ,SRESAKOOLCHAI J ,ZHOU Z H .Sustainability-based lifecycle management for bridge infrastructure using 6D BIM [J].Sustainability ,2020 ,12(6):2436 .
[60]LEE J ,YANG H ,LIM J ,et al .BIM-based preliminary estimation method considering the life cycle cost for decision-making in the early design phase [J].Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering ,2020 ,19(4):384-399.
[61]SLOBODCHIKOV R ,LOHNE BAKKE K ,RAGNAR SVENNEVIG P ,et al .Implementing climate impacts in road infrastructure in the design phase by combining BIM with LCA [J].IOP Conference Series :Earth and Environmental Science ,2019 ,323(1):012089 .
[62]MARZOUK M ,EL-ZAYAT M ,ABOUSHADY A ,et al .Assessing environmental impact indicators in road construction projects in developing countries [J].Sustainability ,2017 ,9(5):843.
[63]沈 琳 ,李 希 胜 ,李 明 瑞 ,等.基 于 BIM-LCA 的 建 筑 环 境 影响评价方法 [J].森林工程 ,2015 ,31(1):149-155.SHEN Lin ,LI Xisheng ,LI Mingrui ,et al .Building environmental impact assessment method based on BIM-LCA [J].Forest Engineering ,2015 ,31(1):149-155.
[64]NAJJAR M ,FIGUEIREDO K ,HAMMAD A W A ,et al .Integrated optimization with building information modeling and life cycle assessment for generating energy efficient buildings [J].Applied Energy ,2019 ,250:1366 -1382 .
[65]RAPOSO C ,RODRIGUES F ,RODRIGUES H .BIM-based LCA assessment of seismic strengthening solutions for reinforced concrete precast industrial buildings [J].Innovative Infrastructure Solutions ,2019 ,4(1):51.
[66]RÖCK M ,HOLLBERG A ,HABERT G ,et al .LCA and BIM :Visualization of environmental potentials in building construction at early design stages [J].Building and Environment ,2018 ,140:153-161.
[67]章驰 ,李希胜 .基于 BIM-LCA 的建筑方案设计优选方法[J].建筑节能 ,2020 ,48(5):33-39.ZHANG Chi ,LI Xisheng .BIM-LCA-based optimization method of building concept design [J].Building Energy Efficiency ,2020 ,48(5):33-39.
[68]SOUST-VERDAGUER B ,LLATAS C ,GARCÍA-MARTÍNEZ A .Critical review of bim-based LCA method to buildings [J].Energy and Buildings ,2017 ,136:110-120.
[69]SANTOS R ,AGUIAR COSTA A ,SILVESTRE J D ,et al .Development of a BIM-based environmental and economic life cycle assessment tool [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2020 ,265:121705 .
[70]JALILZAD E ,VADIEE A ,JOHANSSON P .Achieving a trade-off construction solution using BIM ,an optimization algorithm ,and a multi-criteria decision-making method [J].Buildings ,2019 ,9(4):81.
[71]LU K ,JIANG X Y ,YU J Y ,et al .Integration of life cycle assessment and life cycle cost using building information modeling :A critical review [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2021 ,285:125438 .
[72]WASTIELS L ,DECUYPERE R .Identification and comparison of LCA-BIM integration strategies [J].IOP Conference Series :Earth and Environmental Science ,2019 ,323(1):012101 .[73]SAFARI K ,AZARIJAFARI H .Challenges and opportunities for integrating BIM and LCA :Methodological choices and framework development [J].Sustainable Cities and Society ,2021 ,67:102728 .
[74]SANDBERG M ,MUKKAVAARA J ,SHADRAM F ,et al .Multidisciplinary optimization of life-cycle energy and cost using a BIM-based master model [J].Sustainability ,2019 ,11(1):286.
[75]SANTOS R ,COSTA A A ,SILVESTRE J D ,et al .BIM-based life cycle assessment and life cycle costing of an office building in Western Europe [J].Building and Environment ,2020 ,169:106568 .
[76]SOBHKHIZ S ,TAGHADDOS H ,REZVANI M ,et al .Utilization of semantic web technologies to improve BIM-LCA applications [J].Automation in Construction ,2021 ,130:103842 .
[77]XU J Y ,TENG Y ,PAN W ,et al .BIM-integrated LCA to automate embodied carbon assessment of prefabricated buildings [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2022 ,374:133894 .

Download

Share

COinS