Review of Snow and Ice Melting Techniques for Road and Bridge in Cold Regions

Authors

TANG Liyun, School of Architecture and Civil Engineering , Xi’an University of Science and Technology , Xi’an, Shaanxi 710054 , ChinaFollow
SHAO Haitao, School of Architecture and Civil Engineering , Xi’an University of Science and Technology , Xi’an, Shaanxi 710054 , China
TANG Huaming, Urumqi Hengxin Minsheng Construction and Installation Co ., Ltd., Urumqi , Xinjiang 830000 , China
QIU Peiyong, School of Architecture and Civil Engineering , Xi’an University of Science and Technology , Xi’an, Shaanxi 710054 , China
DU Xiaoqi, School of Architecture and Civil Engineering , Xi’an University of Science and Technology , Xi’an, Shaanxi 710054 , China
ZHANG Lei, School of Architecture and Civil Engineering , Xi’an University of Science and Technology , Xi’an, Shaanxi 710054 , China
PENG Hui, CCCC First Highway Consultants Co ., Ltd., Xi’an, Shaanxi 710075 , China

Abstract

Snow and ice melting of road and bridge surfaces is crucial for traffic safety，but current research on snow and ice melting techniques mainly focuses on engineering effects and technical evaluation，without the analysis and elaboration from the perspective of their mechanisms.To this end，based on the different mechanisms，this study divided snow and ice melting techniques into three types and summarized them：passive deicing，active deicing，and energy utilization deicing.This study systematically evaluated the advantages and disadvantages of traditional deicing methods such as deicing agents and mechanical deicing，analyzed two active deicing techniques，namely inhibitive freezing pavement and phase change material pavement，discussed the environmental-friendly method for road deicing by using phase change materials，and introduced the mechanisms of different energy utilization deicing techniques.This study analyzed the existing road deicing techniques，their actual application effects，and existing problems，to provide foundational support for the research of snow and ice melting on roads and bridges in cold regions.

Publication Date

10-28-2024

DOI

10.14048/j.issn.1671-2579.2024.05.003

First Page

25

Last Page

38

Submission Date

February 2025

Recommended Citation

Liyun, TANG; Haitao, SHAO; Huaming, TANG; Peiyong, QIU; Xiaoqi, DU; Lei, ZHANG; and Hui, PENG (2024) "Review of Snow and Ice Melting Techniques for Road and Bridge in Cold Regions," Journal of China & Foreign Highway: Vol. 44: Iss. 5, Article 3.
DOI: 10.14048/j.issn.1671-2579.2024.05.003
Available at: https://zwgl1980.csust.edu.cn/journal/vol44/iss5/3

Reference

[1]SEEHERMAN J ,LIU Y .Effects of extraordinary snowfall on traffic safety [J].Accident Analysis & Prevention ,2015 ,81:194-203.
[2]WALLMAN C G ,HENRIK ÅSTRÖM .Friction measurement methods and the correlation between road friction and traffic safety :A literature review [J].Vti Meddelanden ,2001(3):367-377.
[3]GRUBER M R ,HOFKO B ,HOFFMANN M ,et al .Deicing performance of common deicing agents for winter maintenance with and without corrosion-inhibiting substances [J].Cold Regions Science and Technology ,2023 ,208:103795 .
[4]周纯秀 .冰雪地区橡胶颗粒沥青混合料应用技术的研究[D].哈尔滨 :哈尔滨工业大学 ,2006 .ZHOU Chunxiu .Study on application technology of rubber granular asphalt mixture in ice and snow area [D].Harbin :Harbin Institute of Technology ,2006 .
[5]《中国公路学报 》编辑部 .中国路面工程学术研究综述 ·2020 [J].中国公路学报 ,2020 ,33(10):1-66.Editorial Department of China Journal of Highway and Transport .Review on China ’ s pavement engineering research 2020 [J].China Journal of Highway and Transport ,2020 ,33(10):1-66.
[6]王华军 ,赵军 ,陈志豪 ,等.太阳能 ‒地热道路融雪系统路面传热特性的数值研究 [J].太阳能学报 ,2007 ,28(6):608-611.WANG Huajun ,ZHAO Jun ,CHEN Zhihao ,et al .Numerical study on heat-transfer behavior of the pavement in road snow-melting system with solar and geothermal energy [J].Acta Energiae Solaris Sinica ,2007 ,28(6):608-611.
[7]党政 ,关文 ,程晓辉 ,等.CFG能源桩用于混凝土路面除冰降温的试验研究 [J].中国公路学报 ,2019 ,32(2):19-30.DANG Zheng ,GUAN Wen ,CHENG Xiaohui ,et al .Experimental study on CFG energy pile for concrete pavement deicing and cooling [J].China Journal of Highway and Transport ,2019 ,32(2):19-30.
[8]谭忆秋 ,张驰 ,徐慧宁 ,等.主动除冰雪路面融雪化冰特性及路用性能研究综述 [J].中国公路学报 ,2019 ,32(4):1-17.TAN Yiqiu ,ZHANG Chi ,XU Huining ,et al .Snow melting and deicing characteristics and pavement performance of active deicing and snow melting pavement [J].China Journal of Highway and Transport ,2019 ,32(4):1-17.
[9]喻文兵 ,李双洋 ,冯文杰 ,等.道路融雪除冰技术现状与发展趋势分析 [J].冰川冻土 ,2011 ,33(4):933-940.YU Wenbing ,LI Shuangyang ,FENG Wenjie ,et al .Snow and ice melting techniques of pavement :State of the art and development tendency [J].Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology ,2011 ,33(4):933-940.
[10]胡雅灵 .道路除雪设备技术与创新研究 [J].中国新技术新产品 ,2010 (18):64.HU Yaling .Research on technology and innovation of road snow removal equipment [J].China New Technologies and Products ,2010 (18):64.
[11]LIU X M ,ZHAO Y ,LIU W Z ,et al .Microwave heating and deicing efficiency for asphalt concrete with SiC ‒ Fe3O4 microwave enhanced functional layer [J].Journal of Cleaner Production ,2022 ,332:130111 .
[12]LIU Z M ,YANG X ,WANG Y D ,et al .Engineering properties and microwave heating induced ice-melting performance of asphalt mixture with activated carbon powder filler [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2019 ,197:50-62.
[13]王剑英 ,王选仓 ,丁龙亭 ,等.除雪化冰路面微波敏感涂层材料与设备 [J].长安大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2018 ,38(5):49-57.WANG Jianying ,WANG Xuancang ,DING Longting ,et al .Microwave sensitive coating materials and equipment for snow removal [J].Journal of Chang ’an University (Natural Science Edition ),2018 ,38(5):49-57.
[14]刘长生 .我国南方道路除冰机振动滚筒的研究 [J].中南林业科技大学学报 ,2010 ,30(9):85-90.LIU Changsheng .Design of vibration drum of highway deicing machine used in South China [J].Journal of Central South University of Forestry & Technology ,2010 ,30(9):85-90.
[15]朱自成 ,张学军 ,王强 ,等.路面复合除冰机的热力射流系统的设计与试验研究 [J].中国农机化学报 ,2015 ,36(1):54-58.ZHU Zicheng ,ZHANG Xuejun ,WANG Qiang ,et al.Design and experimental research of thermal water-jet system used in pavement composite deicing machine [J].Journal of Chinese Agricultural Mechanization ,2015 ,36(1):54-58.
[16]马爱元 ,张利波 ,孙成余 ,等.高氯氧化锌烟尘微波介电特性及温升特性 [J].中南大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2015 ,46(2):410-415.MA Aiyuan ,ZHANG Libo ,SUN Chengyu ,et al.Microwave dielectric properties and temperature increasing characteristics on zinc oxide dust with high content of Cl[J].Journal of Central South University (Science and Technology ),2015 ,46(2):410-415.
[17]李平 ,王梓晗 ,张洪刚 ,等.融雪剂融冰能力评价方法研究[J].公路交通科技 ,2023 ,40(11):85-95.LI Ping ,WANG Zihan ,ZHANG Honggang ,et al .Study on evaluation method for ice-melting capacity of snow-melting agent [J].Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development ,2023 ,40(11):85-95.
[18]吕悦晶 ,党博 ,张志伟 ,等.基于改进 SHRP融冰试验的氯盐融雪剂性能研究 [J].中外公路 ,2024 ,44(3):262-269.LYU Yuejing ,DANG Bo ,ZHANG Zhiwei ,et al .Performance of chlorine salt snow-melting agent based on improved SHRP ice-melting test [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2024 ,44(3):262-269.
[19]VITALIANO D F .An economic assessment of the social costs of highway salting and the efficiency of substituting a new deicing material [J].Journal of Policy Analysis and Management ,1992 ,11(3):397-418.
[20]郭金禹 ,王树轩 .缓蚀型氯化钙融雪剂的开发 [J].盐业与化工 ,2010 ,39(6):12-14.GUO Jinyu ,WANG Shuxuan .Development of anti-corrosive snow-melting agent of calcium chloride [J].Journal of Salt and Chemical Industry ,2010 ,39(6):12-14.
[21]许英梅 ,张秋民 ,张伟 ,等.一种低成本环保型融雪剂的制备与性能研究 [J].辽宁化工 ,2007 ,36(1):10-11,15.XU Yingmei ,ZHANG Qiumin ,ZHANG Wei ,et al.Study on the preparation and performance of low-cost environmental CMA deicers [J].Liaoning Chemical Industry ,2007 ,36(1):10-11,15.
[22]林永波 ,李超 ,魏高亮 ,等.显色环保型融雪剂的研制 [J].环境科学与管理 ,2010 ,35(3):146-149.LIN Yongbo ,LI Chao ,WEI Gaoliang ,et al.Studies on snow-melting agent with colouration and environmental protection [J].Environmental Science and Management ,2010 ,35(3):146-149.
[23]郑武西 ,区桦 ,宗炜 ,等.道路融雪剂 “精细化” 使用技术研究与应用 [J].公路 ,2022 ,67(1):344-348.ZHENG Wuxi ,OU Hua ,ZONG Wei ,et al .Research and application of “fine” application technology of road snow melting agent [J].Highway ,2022 ,67(1):344-348.
[24]中国气象局 .小雪、中雪、大雪、暴雪是如何划分的 ?[EB/OL]. (2009 -11-12) [2024 -02-12].https ://www .cma.gov.cn/2011 xzt/2011 zhuant/ 20111116 _1/2010052703 /201111 /t20111128 _155045 .html .China Meteorological Administration .How are light snow ,moderate snow ,heavy snow ,and blizzard distinguished ? [EB/OL ].(2009 -11-12)[2024 -02-12].https ://www .cma.gov.cn/2011 xzt/2011 zhuant/ 20111116 _1/2010052703 /201111 /t20111128 _155045 .html .
[25]ZHANG Y M ,ZHAO X J ,ZHENG M L .Analysis of engineering performance and environmental impact of asphalt pavement debonding and ice suppression materials[J].Buildings ,2023 ,13(3):689.
[26]张争奇 ,罗要飞 ,赵富强 .储盐类融雪抑冰材料对沥青混合料性能影响研究进展 [J].化工进展 ,2018 ,37(6):2282 -2294 .ZHANG Zhengqi ,LUO Yaofei ,ZHAO Fuqiang .Review of research on the effect of salt storage deicing material on the preformance of asphalt mixture [J].Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress ,2018 ,37(6):2282 -2294 .
[27]CHEN Y Z ,TAN Y Q ,SHE H W ,et al .Characteristics of slow-release ice and snow melting micro-surfacing materials [J]. International Journal of Pavement Engineering ,2023 ,24(2):2120986 .
[28]俞文生 ,张晓春 ,钟科 .高弹蓄盐融冰雪沥青混合料除冰特性 [J].中国矿业大学学报 ,2015 ,44(5):912-916.YU Wensheng ,ZHANG Xiaochun ,ZHONG Ke .De-icing performance of asphalt mixture with snowmelt agent and high-elastic modified asphalt binder [J].Journal of China University of Mining & Technology ,2015 ,44(5):912-916.
[29]张浩军 ,王修山 ,吴大志 ,等.掺V-260主动抑冰沥青混合料路用性能试验研究 [J].公路 ,2015 ,60(8):26-29.ZHANG Haojun ,WANG Xiushan ,WU Dazhi ,et al .Test and study of road performance of V- 260 automatic anti-freezing asphalt mixture [J].Highway ,2015 ,60(8):26-29.
[30]WU S Y ,YANG J ,SUN X Y ,et al .Preparation and characterization of anti-freezing asphalt pavement [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2020 ,236:117579 .
[31]谭忆秋 ,侯明昊 ,单丽岩 ,等.蓄盐沥青路面缓释络合盐填料的研制 [J].建筑材料学报 ,2014 ,17(2):256-260.TAN Yiqiu ,HOU Minghao ,SHAN Liyan ,et al .Development of sustained release complex salt filler for asphalt pavement included salt [J].Journal of Building Materials ,2014 ,17(2):256-260.
[32]周水文 ,林芳 ,张晓华 ,等.低冰点沥青混合料融雪抑冰性能影响因素研究 [J].中外公路 ,2023 ,43(1):207-214.ZHOU Shuiwen ,LIN Fang ,ZHANG Xiaohua ,et al .Influence factors of deicing and thaw performance of asphalt mixture with low freezing point [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2023 ,43(1):207-214.
[33]彭磊 .自融雪沥青路面外加剂制备与运用研究 [D].西安 :长安大学 ,2013 .PENG Lei .Study on preparation and application of self-melting snow asphalt pavement admixture [D].Xi’an:Changan University ,2013 .
[34]李悦 ,李铁山 ,徐玉峰 ,等.多功能自融雪沥青路面的研究与应用 [J].中外公路 ,2012 ,32(6):85-89.LI Yue ,LI Tieshan ,XU Yufeng ,et al .Research and application of multifunctional self-snowmelt asphalt pavement [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2012 ,32(6):85-89.
[35]MENG M Q ,DENG S ,CUI H ,et al .Impact of initial gradation on compaction characteristics and particle crushing behavior of gravel under dynamic loading [J].Powder Technology ,2024 ,447:120216 .
[36]ZHONG K ,SUN M Z ,CHANG R H .Performance evaluation of high-elastic/salt-storage asphalt mixture modified with Mafilon and rubber particles [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2018 ,193:153-161.
[37]肖劲松 ,邹孟秋 .物理 ‒化学综合融雪除冰沥青混合料研究[J].公路 ,2017 ,62(8):248-252.XIAO Jinsong ,ZOU Mengqiu .Study of asphalt mixture for melting snow and ice by physical-chemical combining means [J].Highway ,2017 ,62(8):248-252.
[38]ZOU G L ,CHEN Q ,JIAO Y Q ,et al .Research on deicing performance of high-elastic/salt-storage asphalt mixture containing rubber particle and self-developed salt-storage filler [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2024 ,449:138303 .
[39]陈建民 ,刘东海 ,王锦余 ,等.掺废轮胎橡胶颗粒碎石封层黏结性研究 [J].中外公路 ,2024 ,44(4):127-137.CHEN Jianmin ,LIU Donghai ,WANG Jinyu ,et al .Bonding performance of chip seal containing waste tire rubber particles [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2024 ,44(4):127-137.
[40]HUANG J D ,WANG Q .Retraction Note to :Influence of crumb rubber particle sizes on rutting ,low temperature cracking ,fracture ,and bond strength properties of asphalt binder [J].Materials and Structures ,2022 ,55(2):69.
[41]张晓亮 .橡胶颗粒沥青路面抑冰雪技术研究 [D].西安 :长安大学 ,2014 .ZHANG Xiaoliang .Study on ice and snow suppression technology of rubber particle asphalt pavement [D].Xi’an:Chang’an University ,2014 .
[42]张洪伟 .橡胶颗粒除冰雪沥青路面的研究 [D].西安 :长安大学 ,2009 .ZHANG Hongwei .Study on asphalt pavement with rubber particles to remove ice and snow [D].Xi’an:Chang’an University ,2009 .
[43]张聪 .橡胶颗粒沥青路面耐久性研究 [D].西安 :长安大学,2012 .ZHANG Cong .Study on durability of rubber particle asphalt pavement [D].Xi’an:Chang’an University ,2012 .
[44]ALI MEMON S ,CUI H Z ,ZHANG H ,et al .Utilization of macro encapsulated phase change materials for the development of thermal energy storage and structural lightweight aggregate concrete [J].Applied Energy ,2015 ,139:43-55.
[45]SAKULICH A R ,BENTZ D P .Incorporation of phase change materials in cementitious systems via fine lightweight aggregate [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2012 ,35:483-490.
[46]SOUAYFANE F ,FARDOUN F ,BIWOLE P H .Phase change materials (PCM ) for cooling applications in buildings :A review [J].Energy and Buildings ,2016 ,129:396-431.[47]ATHUKORALLAGE B , DISSANAYAKA T ,SENADHEERA S ,et al .Performance analysis of incorporating phase change materials in asphalt concrete pavements [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2018 ,164:419-432.
[48]KAKAR M R ,REFAA Z ,WORLITSCHEK J ,et al .Use of microencapsulated phase change materials in bitumen to mitigate the thermal distresses in asphalt pavements [M].RILEM Bookseries .Cham :Springer International Publishing ,2018 :129-135.
[49]李莉 .相变材料及其储能混凝土的制备与性能研究 [D].重庆 :重庆大学 ,2010 .LI Li .Study on preparation and properties of phase change materials and their energy storage concrete [D].Chongqing :Chongqing University ,2010 .
[50]HUNGER M ,ENTROP A G ,MANDILARAS I ,et al .The behavior of self-compacting concrete containing micro-encapsulated phase change materials [J].Cement and Concrete Composites ,2009 ,31(10):731-743.
[51]臧初越 .水泥基封装胶囊相变材料的力学和抗冻性能研究[D].徐州 :中国矿业大学 ,2021 .ZANG Chuyue .Study on mechanics and frost resistance of cement-based encapsulated phase change materials [D].Xuzhou :China University of Mining and Technology ,2021 .
[52]ZHAO L ,YU Q F ,LI M ,et al .Preparation and thermal properties of low-temperature composite phase-change materials based on a binary eutectic mixture with expanded graphite :Effect of particle size and mass fraction[J].Journal of Energy Storage ,2021 ,40:102778 .
[53]苟珊 .水泥路面抗凝冰低温相变材料开发与性能研究[D].重庆 :重庆交通大学 ,2019 .GOU Shan .Development and performance study of anti-icing low temperature phase change materials for cement pavement [D].Chongqing :Chongqing Jiaotong University ,2019 .
[54]贾蒲悦 ,武卫东 ,王益聪 .新型 0 ℃相变蓄冷材料制备及蓄冷特性 [J].化工进展 ,2019 ,38(6):2862 -2869 .JIA Puyue ,WU Weidong ,WANG Yicong .Preparation of 0 ℃ phase change material and its cold storage performance in cold-chain logistics [J].Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress ,2019 ,38(6):2862 -2869 .
[55]周孙希 ,章学来 ,刘升 .十四烷 ‒正辛酸有机复合相变材料的制备和性能 [J].储能科学与技术 ,2018 ,7(4):692-697.ZHOU Sunxi ,ZHANG Xuelai ,LIU Sheng .Preparation and thermal property of a tetradecane-octanoic acid eutectic phase change material [J].Energy Storage Science and Technology ,2018 ,7(4):692-697.
[56]HAN C J ,YU X .An innovative energy pile technology to expand the viability of geothermal bridge deck snow melting for different United States regions :Computational assisted feasibility analyses [J].Renewable Energy ,2018 ,123:417-427.
[57]LIU H W ,MAGHOUL P ,BAHARI A ,et al .Feasibility study of snow melting system for bridge decks using geothermal energy piles integrated with heat pump in Canada [J].Renewable Energy ,2019 ,136:1266 -1280 .
[58]PAN P ,WU S P ,XIAO Y ,et al .A review on hydronic asphalt pavement for energy harvesting and snow melting[J].Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews ,2015 ,48:624-634.
[59]吴定意 ,申路 ,陶佳瑜 ,等.新能源在寒区道路桥梁融雪问题的应用技术研究 [J].四川建筑 ,2020 ,40(1):109-110,112.WU Dingyi ,SHEN Lu ,TAO Jiayu ,et al .Study on application technology of new energy in snow melting of roads and bridges in cold regions [J].Sichuan Architecture ,2020 ,40(1):109-110,112.
[60]陈鑫 ,孔纲强 ,刘汉龙 ,等.桥面融雪除冰能量桩热泵系统换热效率现场试验 [J].中国公路学报 ,2022 ,35(11):107-115.CHEN Xin ,KONG Gangqiang ,LIU Hanlong ,et al .Field tests on heat transfer efficiency of bridge deck snow melting and deicing using energy pile heat pump system[J].China Journal of Highway and Transport ,2022 ,35(11):107-115.
[61]任连伟 ,徐健 ,孔纲强 ,等.冬季工况多次温度循环下微型钢管桩群桩热力响应特性现场试验 [J].岩土工程学报 ,2019 ,41(11):2053 -2060 .REN Lianwei ,XU Jian ,KONG Gangqiang ,et al .Field tests on thermal response characteristics of micro steel pile group under multiple temperature cycles in winter conditions [J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering ,2019 ,41(11):2053 -2060 .
[62]FAIZAL M ,BOUAZZA A ,HABERFIELD C ,et al .Axial and radial thermal responses of a field-scale energy pile under monotonic and cyclic temperature changes [J].Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering ,2018 ,144(10):04018072 .
[63]TANG L Y ,CUI Y P ,CHEN J B ,et al.Analysis and research on the difference of design codes for vertical bearing capacity of pile foundation in cold regions [J].Cold Regions Science and Technology ,2023 ,206:103723 .[64]TANG L Y ,YANG L J ,QIU P Y ,et al .Degradation characteristics and bearing capacity model of pile in degraded permafrost [J].Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Geotechnical Engineering ,2022 ,175(4):414-425.
[65]TANG L Y ,WANG K ,DENG L J ,et al .Axial loading behaviour of laboratory concrete piles subjected to permafrost degradation [J].Cold Regions Science and Technology ,2019 ,166:102820 .
[66]PARK S ,LEE D ,LEE S ,et al .Experimental and numerical analysis on thermal performance of large-diameter cast-in-place energy pile constructed in soft ground [J].Energy ,2017 ,118:297-311.
[67]陈智 ,高华雨 ,肖衡林 ,等.温度荷载作用下灌注型能量桩热力响应原位试验研究 [J].防灾减灾工程学报 ,2019 ,39(4):592-598.CHEN Zhi ,GAO Huayu ,XIAO Henglin ,et al .In-situ thermo-mechanical response test of perfusion energy pile under temperature loading [J].Journal of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation Engineering ,2019 ,39(4):592-598.
[68]桂树强 ,程晓辉 .能源桩换热过程中结构响应原位试验研究 [J].岩土工程学报 ,2014 ,36(6):1087 -1094 .GUI Shuqiang ,CHENG Xiaohui .In-situ tests on structural responses of energy piles during heat exchanging process[J].Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering ,2014 ,36(6):1087 -1094 .
[69]郭猛 ,蔡晓晓 ,王京京 ,等.道路融雪除冰技术生命周期内环境负荷分析 [J/OL ].中国公路学报 ,1-16[2024 -06-04].http://kns .cnki.net/kcms/detail/ 61.1313 .U.20240314 .1544 . 002.html .GUO Meng ,CAl Xiaoxiao ,WANG Jingjing ,et al .Analysis of environmental load during the life cycle of road snow melting and deicing technology [J/OL ].China Journal of Highway and Transport ,1-16[2024 -06-04].http://kns .cnki.net/kcms/detail/ 61.1313 .U.20240314 .1544 .002.html .
[70]ZHAO H M ,WU Z M ,WANG S G ,et al .Concrete pavement deicing with carbon fiber heating wires [J].Cold Regions Science and Technology ,2011 ,65(3):413-420.
[71]张登春 ,章照宏 ,袁江雅 ,等.公路桥梁发热电缆除冰系统试验研究 [J].中国安全生产科学技术 ,2015 ,11(11):90-95.ZHANG Dengchun ,ZHANG Zhaohong ,YUAN Jiangya ,et al.Experimental research on deicing system by heating cables for highway bridges [J].Journal of Safety Science and Technology ,2015 ,11(11):90-95.
[72]王锋 ,韩森 ,张丽娟 ,等.融冰雪沥青混合料盐分溶析试验[J].长安大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2010 ,30(6):16-19,55.WANG Feng ,HAN Sen ,ZHANG Lijuan ,et al .Efflorescence experiment of asphalt mixture with salt for melting snow and ice [J].Journal of Chang ’an University (Natural Science Edition ),2010 ,30(6):16-19,55.
[73]ZHU X Y ,ZHANG Q F ,DU Z ,et al .Snow-melting pavement design strategy with electric cable heating system balancing snow melting ,energy conservation ,and mechanical performance [J].Resources ,Conservation and Recycling ,2022 ,177:105970 .
[74]冀晨宇 .碳纤维发热电缆 ‒玻纤格栅沥青混凝土力学性能研究 [D].邯郸 :河北工程大学 ,2022 .JI Chenyu .Study on mechanical properties of carbon fiber heating cable-glass fiber grating asphalt concrete [D].Handan :Hebei University of Engineering ,2022 .
[75]马子鹏 .基于导电橡胶复合材料的电加热融冰雪铺装结构设计及应用研究 [D].长春：吉林大学 ,2024 .MA Zipeng .Design and application research of electrically heated ice and snow melting paving structure based on conductive rubber composite material [D].Changchun :Jilin University ,2024 .
[76]张宗伟 ,何凯 .石墨烯类材料改性沥青的研究进展 [J/OL ].中 外 公 路 ,1-12[2024 -09-23].http://kns .cnki.net/kcms/detail/ 43.1363 .u.20240419 .1900 .002.html .ZHANG Zongwei ,HE Kai .Research progress of graphene modified asphalt [J/OL ].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,1-12[2024 -09-23].http://kns .cnki.net/kcms/detail/43.1363 .u.20240419 .1900 .002.html .
[77]张九思 ,朱珊 ,李婧铭 ,等.不同种类导电相材料在混凝土损伤检测领域的应用前景分析 [J].建筑结构 ,2023 ,53(增刊2):1744 -1747 .ZHANG Jiusi ,ZHU Shan ,LI Jingming ,et al .Analysis of the application prospects of different types of conductive materials in the field of damage detection of conductive concrete [J].Building Structure ,2023 ,53(sup 2):1744 -1747 .
[78]唐丽云 ,王柯 ,杨更社 ,等,基于土体电阻率变化的冻土未冻水含量检测系统及方法 :中国 ,CN106771082 A[P]. 2017 -05-31.TANG Liyun ,WANG Ke ,YANG Gengshe ,et al .Detection system and method of unfrozen water content in frozen soil based on changes in soil resistivity :China ,CN106771082A[P].2017 -05-31.
[79]唐丽云 ,王柯 ,杨更社 ,等.冻土电阻率和温度与冻土未冻水 含 量 的 关 系 模 型 构 建 方 法 :中 国 ,CN106546711 A[P].2017 -03-29.TANG Liyun ,WANG Ke ,YANG Gengshe ,et al.Method for constructing a model of the relationship between frozen soil resistivity ,temperature ,and unfrozen water content :China ,CN106546711 A[P].2017 -03-29.
[80]ZHANG Q Q ,YU Y K ,CHEN W Z ,et al .Outdoor experiment of flexible sandwiched graphite-PET sheets based self-snow-thawing pavement [J].Cold Regions Science and Technology ,2016 ,122:10-17.
[81]韩栓业 .道路融冰雪导电橡胶复合材料特性与发热效应研究 [D].长春 :吉林大学 ,2023 .HAN Shuanye .Study on characteristics and heating effect of conductive rubber composites for road melting snow and ice [D].Changchun :Jilin University ,2023 .
[82]WU J M ,LIU J G ,YANG F .Three-phase composite conductive concrete for pavement deicing [J].Construction and Building Materials ,2015 ,75:129-135.