Post‑Evaluation Method for Decision‑Making and Implementation of Highway Maintenance Projects Based on AHP‑DEMATEL

Authors

YU Wei, Changsha Science and Technology Testing Consulting Co ., Ltd., Changsha , Hunan 410114 , ChinaFollow
YANG Na, Changsha Science and Technology Testing Consulting Co ., Ltd., Changsha , Hunan 410114 , ChinaFollow
LI Jue, School of Traffic & Transportation Engineering , Changsha University of Science & Technology , Changsha , Hunan 410114 , China

Corresponding Author

杨娜，女，硕士，工程师.E-mail：1025879301@qq.com

Abstract

Addressing the current lack of post-evaluation management systems related to highways，particularly highway maintenance，this paper proposed a post-evaluation method for the decision-making and implementation of highway maintenance projects based on the combination of analytic hierarchy process （AHP） and decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory （DEMATEL ）.After building a post-evaluation model for the decision-making and implementation of highway maintenance projects and designing the evaluation process，this paper calculated key factors influencing the post-evaluation of the decision-making and implementation of highway maintenance projects and their respective comprehensive weights.The research results indicate that decision-making can possess higher accuracy and efficiency under the above calculation method，providing a reference for project planning.

Publication Date

10-28-2024

DOI

10.14048/j.issn.1671-2579.2024.05.031

First Page

277

Last Page

283

Submission Date

February 2025

Recommended Citation

Wei, YU; Na, YANG; and Jue, LI (2024) "Post‑Evaluation Method for Decision‑Making and Implementation of Highway Maintenance Projects Based on AHP‑DEMATEL," Journal of China & Foreign Highway: Vol. 44: Iss. 5, Article 31.
DOI: 10.14048/j.issn.1671-2579.2024.05.031
Available at: https://zwgl1980.csust.edu.cn/journal/vol44/iss5/31

Reference

[1]李玉环 ,史小丽 ,高楠 .基于 DEA的高速公路小修保养绩效改进分析 [J].中外公路 ,2023 ,43(2):253-258.LI Yuhuan ,SHI Xiaoli ,GAO Nan .Analysis of expressway routine maintenance performance management based on DEA [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2023 ,43(2):253-258.
[2]刘明歆 ,陈彬 ,刘军涛 ,等.海上风电场发电能力后评估及影响因素分析 [J].西北水电 ,2023 (2):91-95.LIU Mingxin ,CHEN Bin ,LIU Juntao ,et al .Post-evaluation of power generation capacity of offshore wind farm and analysis of its influencing factors [J].Northwest Hydropower ,2023 (2):91-95.
[3]张妍 ,李露 ,马壮林 ,等.公路养护组织方案优化与效益评估[J].中外公路 ,2021 ,41(增刊 2):227-239.ZHANG Yan ,LI Lu ,MA Zhuanglin ,et al .Optimization and benefit evaluation of highway maintenance organization scheme [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2021 ,41(sup 2):227-239.
[4]武阳阳 ,李宝鑫 .基于运行实效的体育场馆类绿色建筑后评估研究 [J].建设科技 ,2021 (20):53-57.WU Yangyang ,LI Baoxin .Research on post-evaluation of stadium green buildings based on operational effectiveness[J].Construction Science and Technology ,2021 (20):53-57.
[5]李彩 .项目后评估体系在高标准农田水利工程的应用[J].农业工程与装备 ,2022 ,49(5):14-16.LI Cai .Application of post project evaluation system in high-standard farmland water conservancy projects [J].Agricultural Engineering and Equipment ,2022 ,49(5):14-16.
[6]郭旺达 ,张金喜 ,张阳光 ,等.基于 IFS-TOPSIS 的预防性养护投资效益评价研究 [J].中外公路 ,2022 ,42(5):246-251.GUO Wangda ,ZHANG Jinxi ,ZHANG Yangguang ,et al .Study on benefit evaluation of preventive maintenance investment based on IFS-TOPSIS [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2022 ,42(5):246-251.
[7]《中国公路学报 》编辑部 .中国交通工程学术研究综述 ·2016 [J].中国公路学报 ,2016 ,29(6):1-161.Editorial Department of China Journal of Highways .Review on China ’ s traffic engineering research progress :2016 [J].China Journal of Highway and Transport ,2016 ,29(6):1-161.
[8]李秀君 ,李春龙 ,李梦晨 ,等.基于多层次模糊灰色耦合理论的高等级公路养护机械配置方案评价 [J].上海理工大学学报 ,2014 ,36(1):86-90,96.LI Xiujun ,LI Chunlong ,LI Mengchen ,et al .Evaluation of highway maintenance machinery configuration planning based on multi-level fuzzy gray coupling theory [J].Journal of University of Shanghai for Science and Technology ,2014 ,36(1):86-90,96.
[9]黄仕鑫 ,陶小飞 ,方少林 ,等.基于 AHP-DEMATEL 云模型的应急能力评估 [J].电力安全技术 ,2021 ,23(8):27-31.HUANG Shixin ,TAO Xiaofei ,FANG Shaolin ,et al .Evaluation of emergency response capability based on AHP-DEMATEL cloud model [J].Electric Safety Technology ,2021 ,23(8):27-31.
[10]刘学强 ,李翼 .基于 AHP-DEMATEL 的海上溢油应急能力评价 [J].广州航海学院学报 ,2023 ,31(3):34-37,43.LIU Xueqiang ,LI Yi .Marine oil spill emergency capability assessment based on AHP-DEMATEL method [J].Journal of Guangzhou Maritime University ,2023 ,31(3):34-37,43.
[11]范玉峰 ,张天航 .基于 AHP-DEMATEL 综合权重与灰色关联分析法的石化厂区消防应急救援能力评估研究 [J].山东化工 ,2024 ,53(3):224-228.FAN Yufeng ,ZHANG Tianhang .Evaluation of fire emergency rescue capability in petrochemical plant based on AHP-DEMATEL comprehensive weight and grey relational analysis [J].Shandong Chemical Industry ,2024 ,53(3):224-228.
[12]杨林 ,高文学 ,李颜强 ,等.基于 AHP-DEMATEL 法综合管廊天然气管道风险评估 [J].煤气与热力 ,2022 ,42(11):1-8.YANG Lin ,GAO Wenxue ,LI Yanqiang ,et al .Risk assessment of natural gas pipeline in utility tunnel based on AHP-DEMATEL method [J].Gas & Heat ,2022 ,42(11):1-8.
[13]薛彦卓 ,周莹 ,鲁阳 ,等.基于模糊 AHP-DEMATEL 的北极冰区船舶冰困风险评价 [J].哈尔滨工程大学学报 ,2022 ,43(7):944-949,992.XUE Yanzhuo ,ZHOU Ying ,LU Yang ,et al .Risk assessment of ships stuck in ice in Arctic ice area based on fuzzy AHP-DEMATEL [J].Journal of Harbin Engineering University ,2022 ,43(7):944-949,992.
[14]武晓炜 .基于 AHP-DEMATEL 城市轨道交通运营安全风险评价研究 [J].技术与市场 ,2021 ,28(12):149-152,154.WU Xiaowei .Study on safety risk assessment of urban rail transit operation based on AHP-DEMATEL [J].Technology and Market ,2021 ,28(12):149-152,154.
[15]谢军梅 ,甘旭升 ,王明华 ,等.基于模糊 AHP-DEMATEL-VIKOR的战术训练空域规划方案安全性评估 [J].火力与指挥控制 ,2023 ,48(9):26-35.XIE Junmei ,GAN Xusheng ,WANG Minghua ,et al .Safety evaluation for tactical training airspace planning scheme based on fuzzy AHP-DEMATEL-VIKOR method [J].Fire Control & Command Control ,2023 ,48(9):26-35.
[16]吴昊 ,赖宇阳 ,熊智辉 ,等.基于模糊 AHP-DEMATEL-VIKOR的电力终端安全性评估方法 [J].信息安全研究 ,2023 ,9(4):382-389.WU Hao ,LAI Yuyang ,XIONG Zhihui ,et al .Evaluation method of power terminal security based on fuzzy AHP-DEMATEL-VIKOR [J].Journal of Information Security Research ,2023 ,9(4):382-389.
[17]梁润娥 ,邱云海 .基于层次分析法的某中层滑坡危险性分析 [J].南方国土资源 ,2018 (6):29-31.LIANG Run ’e,QIU Yunhai .Risk analysis of a middle-level landslide based on analytic hierarchy process [J].Land and Resources of Southern China ,2018 (6):29-31.
[18]许嘉慧 ,孙德亮 ,王月 ,等.基于 GIS与改进层次分析法的奉节县滑坡易发性区划 [J].重庆师范大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2020 ,37(2):36-44,2,142.XU Jiahui ,SUN Deliang ,WANG Yue ,et al .Landslide susceptibility mapping of Fengjie County based on GIS and improved analytic hierarchy process [J].Journal of Chongqing Normal University (Natural Science ),2020 ,37(2):36-44,2,142.
[19]刘超群 ,武忠 .基于 AHP和DEMATEL 的可再生能源技术商业化影响因素研究 [J].科技管理研究 ,2015 ,35(1):107-112,116.LIU Chaoqun ,WU Zhong .Research on the factors of renewable energy technology commercialization based on AHP and DEMATEL method [J].Science and Technology Management Research ,2015 ,35(1):107-112,116.
[20]刘宏 ,孙浩 .基于 DEMATEL-ANP 的PPP项目融资风险分析 [J].系统科学学报 ,2018 ,26(1):131-135.LIU Hong ,SUN Hao .Based on DEMATEL-ANP of PPP project financing risk analysis [J].Chinese Journal of Systems Science ,2018 ,26(1):131-135.