Review of Evaluation Methods for Mixing Workability of Asphalt Mixture

Authors

DONG Fuqiang, College of Civil and Transportation Engineering , Hohai University Nanjing , Jiangsu 210098 , ChinaFollow
ZU Yuanzhe, College of Civil and Transportation Engineering , Hohai University Nanjing , Jiangsu 210098 , China
YU Xin, College of Civil and Transportation Engineering , Hohai University Nanjing , Jiangsu 210098 , China ;School of Traffic & Transportation Engineering , Changsha University of Science & Technology , Changsha , Hunan 410114 , ChinaFollow
CHEN Bei, College of Civil and Transportation Engineering , Hohai University Nanjing , Jiangsu 210098 , China
LIU Lin, Jiangsu Xiandai Road & Bridge Co ., Ltd., Nanjing , Jiangsu 210049 , China

Corresponding Author

于新，男，博士，教授，博士生导师.E-mail：yuxin2009@hhu.edu.cn

Abstract

To clarify the evaluation methods an d research status of mixing workability of asphalt mixture， by consulting relevant research literature in China and abroad and analyzing different evaluation methods，indexes，and research findings of the workability of asphalt mixture，the applicability and evaluation effects of different workability evaluation methods were systematically summarized，and the comparative analysis and comprehensive review were made on the main influencing factors of the mixing workability.The results show that in most evaluation methods for the mixing workability of asphalt mixture，corresponding indexes are constructed to quantitatively evaluate the workability by quantifying the resistance or energy consumption in the mixing process.Besides，in some other evaluation methods，workability can be evaluated by taking the compaction volume index or work effectiveness as indirect verification.The material composition and mixing conditions in the mixture directly affect the workability of the asphalt mixture.In addition，the improved workability can not only improve the forming and compaction performance of the mixture but also enhance the quality of road engineering.The improvement and enhancement of the evaluation method for the workability of asphalt mixture and the corresponding evaluation indexes can evaluate the workability of asphalt mixture more accurately and reasonably，which can promote the application of new road engineering technology and reduce energy consumption，pollutants，and carbon emissions.

Publication Date

10-28-2024

DOI

10.14048/j.issn.1671-2579.2024.05.009

First Page

83

Last Page

96

Submission Date

February 2025

Recommended Citation

Fuqiang, DONG; Yuanzhe, ZU; Xin, YU; Bei, CHEN; and Lin, LIU (2024) "Review of Evaluation Methods for Mixing Workability of Asphalt Mixture," Journal of China & Foreign Highway: Vol. 44: Iss. 5, Article 9.
DOI: 10.14048/j.issn.1671-2579.2024.05.009
Available at: https://zwgl1980.csust.edu.cn/journal/vol44/iss5/9

Reference

[1]《中国公路学报 》编辑部 .中国路面工程学术研究综述 ·2020 [J].中国公路学报 ,2020 ,33(10):1-66.Editorial Department of China Journal of Highway and Transport .Review on China ’s pavement engineering research ·2020 [J].China Journal of Highway and Transport ,2020 ,33(10):1-66.
[2]张肖宁 ,尹应梅 ,邹桂莲 .不同空隙率沥青混合料的粘弹性能 [J].中国公路学报 ,2010 ,23(4):1-7.ZHANG Xiaoning ,YIN Yingmei ,ZOU Guilian .Viscoelastic performance of asphalt mixture with different void contents [J].China Journal of Highway and Transport ,2010 ,23(4):1-7.
[3]唐娴 ,刘建超 ,谢淑琴 .沥青混合料工作性路用性能的探索[J].铁道建筑 ,2007 ,47(9):92-93.TANG Xian ,LIU Jianchao ,XIE Shuqin .Exploration on workability of asphalt mixtures for road use [J].Railway Engineering ,2007 ,47(9):92-93.
[4]董满生 ,余志平 ,鹿婧 ,等.考虑温度效应的沥青混合料粘弹性力学模型 [J].固体力学学报 ,2014 ,35(增刊 1):165-172.DONG Mansheng ,YU Zhiping ,LU Jing ,et al .Viscoelastic constitutive model of asphalt mixtures considering temperature effect [J].Chinese Journal of Solid Mechanics ,2014 ,35(sup 1):165-172.
[5]权磊 ,田波 ,何哲 ,等.低坍落度路面混凝土工作性评价指标研究 [J].公路交通科技 ,2020 ,37(5):11-19.QUAN Lei ,TIAN Bo ,HE Zhe ,et al .Study on evaluation indicators for workability of low-slump pavement concrete[J].Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development ,2020 ,37(5):11-19.
[6]胡师杰 ,权磊 ,凌海宇 ,等.液化剂对混凝土工作性能影响的试验研究 [J].混凝土 ,2018 (9):100-102.HU Shijie ,QUAN Lei ,LING Haiyu ,et al .Research on the influence of the concrete working performance with the liquifier [J].Concrete ,2018 (9):100-102.
[7]李淑萍 ,李亚飞 ,陈景 ,等.胶粉与 RET复合 SBS改性沥青老化前后流变特性及其混合料性能研究 [J].公路工程 ,2017 ,42(3):112-120,158.LI Shuping ,LI Yafei ,CHEN Jing ,et al .Study on the rheological properties and performance of rubber and RET modified SBS asphalt before and after aging [J].Highway Engineering ,2017 ,42(3):112-120,158.
[8]SHARMA A ,RANSINCHUNG G D ,KUMAR P ,et al .Design mixture of RAP-HMA pavements :A review [J].IOP Conference Series :Materials Science and Engineering ,2021 ,1075 (1):012025 .
[9]SHENOY A .Determination of the temperature for mixing aggregates with polymer-modified asphalts [J].International Journal of Pavement Engineering ,2001 ,2(1):33-47.
[10]王春 ,郝培文 .改性沥青混合料拌和压实温度确定方法[J].公路 ,2020 ,65(8):32-36.WANG Chun ,HAO Peiwen .Determination of the mixing and compaction temperature of modified-asphalt mixture[J].Highway ,2020 ,65(8):32-36.
[11]彭波 ,邓海龙 ,曹世江 ,等.热拌沥青混合料碳排放量化与评价体系 [J].长安大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2019 ,39(3):1-9.PENG Bo ,DENG Hailong ,CAO Shijiang ,et al .Carbon emission quantification and evaluation system of hot mix asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Chang ’an University (Natural Science Edition ),2019 ,39(3):1-9.
[12]黄波 ,李超源 ,郝治 ,等.集料密度差异及成型温度对沥青混合料配合比的影响研究 [J].中外公路 ,2022 ,42(3):180-185.HUANG Bo ,LI Chaoyuan ,HAO Zhi ,et al .Study on influence of aggregate density difference and compaction temperature on mixing proportions of asphalt mixture [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2022 ,42(3):180-185.
[13]刘福明 ,吴迪 ,何庆德 ,等.纤维稳定剂对排水沥青混合料抗水温循环损伤能力的影响 [J].中外公路 ,2023 ,43(1):194-198.LIU Fuming ,WU Di ,HE Qingde ,et al .Study on effect of fiber stabilizers on water temperature cycle damage resistance of drainage asphalt mixtures [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2023 ,43(1):194-198.
[14]郭乃胜 ,尤占平 ,谭忆秋 ,等.考虑均匀性的沥青混合料最佳沥青用量确定方法 [J].交通运输工程学报 ,2017 ,17(1):1-10.GUO Naisheng ,YOU Zhanping ,TAN Yiqiu ,et al .Determination method of optimum asphalt content in asphalt mixture under considering homogeneity [J].Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering ,2017 ,17(1):1-10.
[15]MARVILLET J ,BOUGAULT P .Workability of bituminous mixes :Development of a workability meter [J].Association of Asphalt Paving Technologists (AAPT ),1979 ,48:91-110.
[16]GUDIMETTLA J M ,COOLEY L A Jr ,BROWN E R .Workability of hot-mix asphalt [J].Transportation Research Record :Journal of the Transportation Research Board ,2004 ,1891 (1):229-237.
[17]TAO M J ,MALLICK R B .Effects of warm-mix asphalt additives on workability and mechanical properties of reclaimed asphalt pavement material [J].Transportation Research Record :Journal of the Transportation Research Board ,2009 ,2126 (1):151-160.
[18]MOGAWER W S ,AUSTERMAN A J ,KLUTTZ R ,et al .High-performance thin-lift overlays with high reclaimed asphalt pavement content and warm-mix asphalt technology [J].Transportation Research Record :Journal of the Transportation Research Board ,2012 ,2293 (1):18-28.
[19]BENNERT T ,REINKE G ,MOGAWER W ,et al .Assessment of workability and compactability of warm-mix asphalt [J].Transportation Research Record :Journal of the Transportation Research Board ,2010 ,2180 (1):36-47.
[20]WEST R ,WATSON D E ,TURNER P ,et al .Mixing and compaction temperatures of asphalt binders in hot-mix asphalt [J].NCHRP Report ,2010 ,648(1） ：2-148.
[21]KHALIL S M ,ARSHAD A K ,RAHMAN M Y A .The development of workability measurement for asphalt mixture using transducer by torque [J].International Journal of Pavement Research and Technology ,2012 ,5:203-208.
[22]ALI A ,ABBAS A ,NAZZAL M ,et al .Workability evaluation of foamed warm-mix asphalt [J].Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering ,2014 ,26(6):04014011 .
[23]侯曙光 .热拌与温拌沥青混合料和易性试验 [J].南京工业大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2011 ,33(5):36-39.HOU Shuguang .Workability experiment of hot asphalt mixture and warm asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Nanjing University of Technology (Natural Science Edition ),2011 ,33(5):36-39.
[24]汪海年 ,郝培文 .热拌沥青混合料的工作性测试新方法[J].中外公路 ,2006 ,26(2):194-196.WANG Hainian ,HAO Peiwen .A new method for workability test of hot mix asphalt mixtures [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2006 ,26(2):194-196.
[25]汪德才 ,郝培文 ,刘娜 ,等.乳化沥青冷再生混合料和易性指标及影响因素 [J].北京工业大学学报 ,2016 ,42(6):919-925.WANG Decai ,HAO Peiwen ,LIU Na ,et al .Workability indicator for emulsified asphalt recycled mixture and influence factors [J].Journal of Beijing University of Technology ,2016 ,42(6):919-925.
[26]郭平 ,段凌云 .Sasobit温拌沥青混合料和易性研究 [J].山东农业大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2012 ,43(1):119-123.GUO Ping ,DUAN Lingyun .Research on the workability of sasobit warm mix asphalt [J].Journal of Shandong Agricultural University (Natural Science Edition ),2012 ,43(1):119-123.
[27]张志强 ,陈冬 ,段鑫明 ,等.基于柔韧性改善的纤维高模量沥青混合料技术研究 [J].森林工程 ,2022 ,38(3):153-162.ZHANG Zhiqiang ,CHEN Dong ,DUAN Xinming ,et al .Technique research on performance of high modulus asphalt mixture with fiber based on flexibility [J].Forest Engineering ,2022 ,38(3):153-162.
[28]张琛 ,汪海年 ,尤占平 ,等.橡胶沥青混合料和易性与压实特性的相关性 [J].东南大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2016 ,46(1):202-208.ZHANG Chen ,WANG Hainian ,YOU Zhanping ,et al .Correlation between workability and compaction property of rubber asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Southeast University (Natural Science Edition ),2016 ,46(1):202-208.
[29]张庆 ,侯德华 ,刘廷国 .水固化型聚合物改性乳化沥青混合料性能研究 [J].材料导报 ,2020 ,34(增刊 2):1612 -1617 .ZHANG Qing ,HOU Dehua ,LIU Tingguo .Study on mechanical properties of water-curable polymer modified emulsified asphalt mixture [J].Materials Reports ,2020 ,34(sup 2):1612 -1617 .
[30]张争奇 ,吴瑞环 ,季社鹏 .改性沥青混合料拌和及压实温度的确定方法 [J].公路交通科技 ,2013 ,30(8):6-11.ZHANG Zhengqi ,WU Ruihuan ,JI Shepeng .An approach to determine mixing and compaction temperatures for modified asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development ,2013 ,30(8):6-11.
[31]甘新立 ,郑南翔 ,侯月琴 ,等.再生 SBS改性沥青混合料的施工温度确定 [J].建筑材料学报 ,2015 ,18(5):808-812.GAN Xinli ,ZHENG Nanxiang ,HOU Yueqin ,et al .Determination of construction temperature of recycled SBS modified asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Building Materials ,2015 ,18(5):808-812.
[32]李宁利 ,李铁虎 ,陈华鑫 ,等.改性沥青混合料拌和与压实温度确定方法综述 [J].材料导报 ,2007 ,21(8):92-95.LI Ningli ,LI Tiehu ,CHEN Huaxin ,et al .Summarization on methods in defining mixing and compaction temperatures for modified asphalt mixture [J].Materials Review ,2007 ,21(8):92-95.
[33]张宜洛 ,郭科 ,赵少宗 ,等.改性沥青混合料施工温度的确定[J].江苏大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2016 ,37(6):740-744.ZHANG Yiluo ,GUO Ke ,ZHAO Shaozong ,et al .Determination of construction temperature for modified asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Jiangsu University (Natural Science Edition ),2016 ,37(6):740-744.
[34]张翠红 ,焦生杰 ,曹学鹏 ,等.水泥乳化沥青混合料施工和易性评价方法及影响因素 [J].长安大学学报 (自然科学版),2018 ,38(1):41-48.ZHANG Cuihong ,JIAO Shengjie ,CAO Xuepeng ,et al .Evaluation method and influencing factors for construction workability of cement-emulsified asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Chang ’an University (Natural Science Edition ),2018 ,38(1):41-48.
[35]张琛 ,汪海年 ,王宠惠 .多年冻土区温拌橡胶沥青混合料的性能及适用性 [J].合肥工业大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2017 ,40(9):1254 -1259 .ZHANG Chen ,WANG Hainian ,WANG Chonghui .Performance and applicability of rubberized warm asphalt mixture in permafrost regions [J].Journal of Hefei University of Technology (Natural Science ),2017 ,40(9):1254 -1259 .
[36]张强 ,高学凯 ,梁春雨 .热再生沥青混合料低温蠕变行为及黏弹性分析 [J].中外公路 ，2022 ,42（2） ：218-222.ZHANG Qiang ，GAO Xuekai ，LIANG Chunyu .Creep behavior and viscoelastic analysis of hot recycled asphalt mixture at low temperature [J].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ,2022，42(2):218-222.
[37]刘黎萍 ,刘宁 ,孙立军 .沥青混合料的和易性测试装置及和易性评价方法 :中国，CN111060680 B[P].2022 -01-25.LIU Liping ,LIU Ning ,SUN Lijun .Workability testing device and workability evaluation method for asphalt mixture：China，CN111060680 B[P].2022 -01-25.
[38]于新 ,徐波 ,邓德毅 ,等.一种基于搅拌电流值的沥青混合料和易性检测装置及检测方法 ：中国，CN104297294 A[P].2015 -01-21.YU Xin ,XU Bo ,DENG Deyi ,et al .Asphalt mixture workability detection device and detection method based on stirring current value ：China，CN104297294 A[P].2015 -01-21.
[39]延西利 ,景宏君 ,游庆龙 ,等.沥青混合料的拌和流动特性及和易性指数 [J].土木工程学报 ,2019 ,52(10):120-128.YAN Xili ,JING Hongjun ,YOU Qinglong ,et al .Mixing flow characteristic and workability index of asphalt mixtures [J].China Civil Engineering Journal ,2019 ,52(10):120-128.
[40]颜建春 ,邹前 ,王晓磊 ,等.配合比设计参数对沥青混合料拌和和易性的影响研究 [J].西部交通科技 ,2022 (5):92-95.YAN Jianchun ,ZOU Qian ,WANG Xiaolei ,et al .Study on the influence of mix design parameters on the mixing workability of asphalt mixture [J].Western China Communications Science & Technology ,2022 (5):92-95.
[41]刘聂玚子 ,刘洪海 ,荣鑫 ,等.确定改性沥青混合料拌和温度的功率法 [J].华中科技大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2021 ,49(7):44-48.LIU Nieyangzi ,LIU Honghai ,RONG Xin ,et al .Stirring power method to determine mixing temperature of modified asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Huazhong University of Science and Technology (Natural Science Edition ),2021 ,49(7):44-48.
[42]HESAMI E ,BIRGISSON B ,KRINGOS N .Effect of mixing sequence on the workability and performance of asphalt mixtures [J].Road Materials and Pavement Design ,2015 ,16(sup 2):197-213.
[43]MONGKOL K ,CHATURABONG P ,SUWANNAPLAI A .Effect of bagasse and coconut peat fillers on asphalt mixture workability [J].Coatings ,2020 ,10(12):1262 .
[44]王笑风 ,苏青山 ,王振军 .橡胶粉纤维沥青混合料高温性能及施工和易性 [J].武汉理工大学学报 (交通科学与工程版 ),2006 ,30(5):846-849.WANG Xiaofeng ,SU Qingshan ,WANG Zhenjun .High temperature stability and workability of crumb rubber-modified and fibers-reinforced asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Wuhan University of Technology (Transportation Science & Engineering ),2006 ,30(5):846-849.
[45]王海林 ,李江 ,陈忠达 ,等.乳化沥青混合料技术性能评价方法研究 [J].公路交通科技 ,2004 ,21(6):44-46.WANG Hailin ,LI Jiang ,CHEN Zhongda ,et al .Study on performance evaluation method for emulsified asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development ,2004 ,21(6):44-46.
[46]牛维宏 ,徐清 ,陈治君 ,等.硫铝酸盐水泥 -乳化沥青混合料性能影响因素研究 [J].新型建筑材料 ,2021 ,48(3):156-160.NIU Weihong ,XU Qing ,CHEN Zhijun ,et al .Research on influencing factors of R ·SAC-emulsified asphalt mixture performance [J].New Building Materials ,2021 ,48(3):156-160.
[47]ROOZBAHANY E G ,PARTL M N .A new test to study the flow of mixtures at early stages of compaction [J].Materials and Structures ,2016 ,49(9):3547 -3558 .
[48]杨跃焕 ,姚雄 ,宋圣霞 ,等.沥青混合料的工作和易性试验研究 [J].材料导报 ,2013 ,27(增刊 1):309-313.YANG Yuehuan ,YAO Xiong ,SONG Shengxia ,et al .Experimental investigation of workability for asphalt mixtures [J].Materials Reports ,2013 ,27(sup 1):309-313.
[49]何亮 ,何兆益 ,凌天清 ,等.温拌橡胶沥青混合料施工和易性研究 [J].功能材料 ,2015 ,46(20):20102 -20107 .HE Liang ,HE Zhaoyi ,LING Tianqing ,et al .Researchon construction workability of asphalt-rubber mixture with warm mix additives [J].Journal of Functional Materials ,2015 ,46(20):20102 -20107 .
[50]师航祺 .基于剪切压实仪的沥青混合料压实和易性研究[D].北京 :北京建筑大学 ,2017 .SHI Hangqi .Evaluation of asphalt mixture compaction workability based on shear compactor [D].Beijing :Beijing University of Civil Engineering and Architecture ,2017 .
[51]南秋彩 .温拌沥青混合料压实特性影响因素研究 [J].重庆交通大学学报 (自然科学版 ),2019 ,38(12):63-68.NAN Qiucai .Influencing factors of compaction characteristics of warm mix asphalt mixture [J].Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong University (Natural Science ),2019 ,38(12):63-68.
[52]袁剑波 ,殷婵 ,冯新军 ,等.多聚磷酸 /脱硫胶粉复合改性沥青的制备及性能研究 [J/OL ].中外公路 ,1-10[2024 -06-15].http://kns .cnki.net/kcms/detail/ 43.1363 .U.20240614 .1606 . 003.html .YUAN Jianbo ,YIN Chan ,FENG Xinjun ,et al .Preparation and performance study of polyphosphoric Acid/Desulfurized crumb rubber composite modified asphalt [J/OL ].Journal of China & Foreign Highway ，1-10[2024 -06-15].http://kns .cnki.net/kcms/detail/ 43.1363 .U.20240614 .1606 . 003.html .
[53]杨彦海 ,刘梦晴 ,孙贯益 .温拌沥青混合料可压实性与路用性能分析 [J].公路 ,2016 ,61(1):32-35.YANG Yanhai ,LIU Mengqing ,SUN Guanyi .Analysis of the compatibility and road performance of warm mix asphalt [J].Highway ,2016 ,61(1):32-35.
[54]唐娴 ,刘建超 ,谢淑琴 .沥青混合料工作性路用性能的探索[J].铁道建筑 ,2007 ,47(9):92-93.TANG Xian ,LIU Jianchao ,XIE Shuqin .Exploration on workability of asphalt mixture for road use [J].Railway Engineering ,2007 ,47(9):92-93.
[55]刘文强 ,熊竹 .沥青混合料工作性及其影响因素试验研究[J].公路工程 ,2014 ,39(1):256-262.LIU Wenqiang ,XIONG Zhu .Experimental study on asphalt mixture workability and its impact factors [J].Highway Engineering ,2014 ,39(1):256-262.
[56]季社鹏 .沥青混合料工作性及施工质量控制研究 [D].西安:长安大学 ,2012 .JI Shepeng .Study on asphalt mixture workability and construction quality control [D].Xi’an:Chang’an University ,2012 .
[57]李昂 .不同性质沥青混合料的变速拌和及和易性指数研究[D].西安 :长安大学 ,2017 .LI Ang .Experiment at different mixing velocities and workability index of asphalt mixture with different bitumen [D].Xi’an:Chang’an University ,2017 .
[58]延西利 ,田辉黎 ,延喜乐 ,等.沥青混合料的变速拌和功率测试与拌和流变模型 [J].交通运输工程学报 ,2016 ,16(3):1-7.YAN Xili ,TIAN Huili ,YAN Xile ,et al .Mixing power measurement at different mixing velocities and mixing rheological model of bituminous mixture [J].Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering ,2016 ,16(3):1-7.